Pioneers Moving On
Baseball
| Past Player (2019) | New Team |
| Jordan Jackson | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Zeke Lecomte | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Chase Haley | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Colin Kriminger | Montreat (NAIA) |
| Dalton Heath | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Past Player (2018) | New Team |
| Chase Douglas | Southern Illinois (NCAA D1) |
| Baylor Steelman | Bethel TN (NAIA) |
| Jake Lyle | East Tennessee St. (NCAA D1) |
| Danny Lara | Bethel TN (NAIA) |
| Antonio Costas | Bethel TN (NAIA) |
| Jacob Cole | Tennessee Tech (NCAA D1) |
| Brent Richey | Lincoln Memorial (NCAA D2) |
| Carson McClure | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Colin Hopkins | Indiana (NCAA D1) |
| James Hatcher | Cumberland (TN) (NAIA) |
| Joe McNamee | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Past Player (2017) | New Team |
| Eddie McDaniels | Harris – Cumberland (NAIA) |
| Tyler Hicks | Carson Newman (NCAA D2) |
| Drew Hall | Memphis (NCAA D1) |
| Richard Constantine | Western Kentucky (NCAA D1) |
| Daniel Lankster | Trevecca (NCAA D2) |
| Alex Lyon | Southern Illinois (NCAA D1) |
| Ben Wiley | Lincoln Memorial (NCAA D2) |
| Past Player (2016) | New Team |
| Barrett Croslin | Midway University (NAIA) |
| Carter Bair | MTSU (NCAA D1) |
| Cameron Bair | Davenport (NAIA) (NCAA D2) |
| Justin Wilson | Vanderbilt (NCAA D1) |
| Brandon LaBoy | Milligan (NAIA) |
| DeAires Moses | MLB Seattle Mariners |
Men's Basketball
| Past Player (2018-19) | New Team |
| Jabori Murphy | Kentucky Christian University |
| Jordan Buchanan | Kentucky Christian University |
| Byron Dean | Silver Lake College (Wisconsin) |
| Past Player | New Team |
| Daniel Hill | Lane College |
| Medardas Jurjonas | Brescia University |
| Emmanuel Malumba | Brescia University |
| Joseph Evans | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Casey Farrell | Tennessee Temple University |
| Jeff Harper | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Creshaun Holt | Mountain State University |
| Robert Riley | Bryan College |
| Jeremy Simmons | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Kenneth "KJ" Stripling | Mountain State University |
| David Warner | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Jeremy Kennedy | Landers University |
| Hunter Harris | East Tennessee State University |
| Jay Starks | Western Kentucky University |
| E.J. Perry | Cumberland University |
| Paul Williams | Cumberland University |
| Alex Marzette | University of Southern Indiana |
| Ryan Yeates | Henderson State University |
| Barry Robertson | West Texas A&M University |
| Walter Wright | University of Texas-Permian Basin |
| Martez Harris | Indiana University-Southeast |
| Wesley Brown | Mid-Continent University |
| Reid Burke | Carson Newman University |
| Pablo Diaz | Tennessee Temple University |
| Tre Coleman | Salem International University |
| C. J. Cummings | Brescia University |
| Jamaal Brantley | Cameron University |
| Joe Wilbert | Life University |
| Justin Perry | Life University |
| Joseph Prince | West Texas State |
| James Mathis | Trevecca |
| Connor Peach | Martin Methodist |
| Wray Fuller | Bryan College |
| Lucas Jones | Southern Utah University |
| Quinton Wood | Reinhardt University |
Who's gone pro?
| Past Player | New Team |
|---|---|
| Astral Guerrier | Bryan College/Professional (ABA Nashville Soul) |
| Julius Virgo | Martin Methodist College/Professional (Nashville Soul) |
| Carlos Woodard | Pikeville College/Professional (ABA Nashville Soul) |
| Alex Marzette | Professional Overseas |
| Jermel Kennedy | Professional Overseas |
| Jaraun Burrows | Professional Overseas |
| Jeff Harper | Professional Overseas |